a different perspective
Your inner critic might just be missing some important communication skills.
Many years ago, Ann was helping her roommate paint their Chicago apartment. A rickety ladder was standing in the hall when Leone’s cat, Frostbite, decided to leap onto the paint shelf. Ladder, cat, and everything came crashing to the floor. Ann rushed over to help untangle him, and instead of welcoming her, Frostbite attacked. Claws out, yowling, completely wild.
From Ann’s Article, “Radical Gentleness: The transformation of the Inner critic”
“It didn’t take long for me to forgive him. Of course he attacked me; he was terrified, panicky, trapped, and desperate. All I had to do was see the desperation instead of the attack, and my compassion opened up easily, despite the claw marks on my hand.”
“The same was true of the inner criticizing process. If I wanted to help someone have compassion for a part of them that was critical, what I needed to do was invite them to consider that the criticizing part might be afraid. This always worked.”
In that stress-filled moment, Frostbite was too overwhelmed by fear to ask for help in a way that wasn’t harmful. For many of us, our inner critics are in that same place. They’re afraid, and that fear comes out as an attack.
When you can turn toward that fierce, frightened part with curiosity and patience, something shifts. It no longer needs to pull the proverbial fire alarm to get your attention. It can begin to tell you what it’s actually afraid of. And from there, you can move forward… with clarity (and without the claws).
“There are no enemies inside. Every part of us is trying to save our lives.“
– ann weiser cornell
a different perspective
Your inner critic might just be missing some important communication skills.
Many years ago, Ann was helping her roommate paint their Chicago apartment. A rickety ladder was standing in the hall when Leone’s cat, Frostbite, decided to leap onto the paint shelf. Ladder, cat, and everything came crashing to the floor. Ann rushed over to help untangle him, and instead of welcoming her, Frostbite attacked. Claws out, yowling, completely wild.
From Ann’s Article, “Radical Gentleness: The transformation of the Inner critic”
“It didn’t take long for me to forgive him. Of course he attacked me; he was terrified, panicky, trapped, and desperate. All I had to do was see the desperation instead of the attack, and my compassion opened up easily, despite the claw marks on my hand.”
“The same was true of the inner criticizing process. If I wanted to help someone have compassion for a part of them that was critical, what I needed to do was invite them to consider that the criticizing part might be afraid. This always worked.”
In that stress-filled moment, Frostbite was too overwhelmed by fear to ask for help in a way that wasn’t harmful. For many of us, our inner critics are in that same place. They’re afraid, and that fear comes out as an attack.
When you can turn toward that fierce, frightened part with curiosity and patience, something shifts. It no longer needs to pull the proverbial fire alarm to get your attention. It can begin to tell you what it’s actually afraid of. And from there, you can move forward… with clarity (and without the claws).
“There are no enemies inside. Every part of us is trying to save our lives.“
– ann weiser cornell
what usually doesn’t work
Trying to “fix” or quiet the inner critic
Arguing with the critical voice
Trying to silence or suppress it
Replacing negative thoughts with positive ones
Telling yourself to “be kinder to yourself”
Pushing the critic away or trying to exile it
Pushed away, the inner critic comes back. Often louder than before. As Ann writes: if we criticize the critic, we are perpetuating the problem.
the irf approach
Meeting the inner critic with curiosity
Recognizing the critic as a scared part of you
Turning toward it with curiosity and compassion instead of resistance
Really listening to what it’s worried about
Holding it in Presence: neither pushing away nor being overwhelmed by it
Letting it soften in its own time
When a criticizing part feels genuinely heard, it relaxes. Not because it’s been conquered, but because its fear has finally been acknowledged.
“An inner criticizing part is any part of you that believes that you or another part of you has to change in order for you to be OK.“
— Ann Weiser Cornell, Radical Gentleness
Frequently Asked Questions About Inner Critics
Here are some of the most common questions we hear from people exploring Inner Relationship Focusing as a way to navigate inner criticizing voices. If you have a question that isn’t answered here, reach out to us.
What is an inner critic?
An inner critic often shows up as a harsh internal voice that judges, criticizes, or tells you that you’re not enough. It can sound like “Why am I always so stupid?” or “I should be further along by now” or simply a persistent feeling of not measuring up.
In Inner Relationship Focusing, we think of the inner critic not as a fixed, essential part of who you are, but as a part of you that is “criticizing right now,” a temporary state that came about for a reason, and one that can change.
Why do I have an inner critic?
The inner critic often develops as a protective response, a part of you that learned, at some point, that criticism or control was a way to keep you safe, acceptable, or loved. It criticizes because it’s afraid that without that pressure, something bad will happen.
As Ann has found over decades of working with people: when you look closely at a criticizing part, you almost always find that it believes it is helping. It criticizes because it’s afraid that without that pressure, nothing will ever change.
Why does my inner critic get louder when I try to silence it, or ignore it?
Because pushing any part of your inner experience away doesn’t make it disappear. It just teaches it to be louder, harsher, and more insistent to get your attention. As Ann writes in “Radical Gentleness”: “You cannot ‘get rid of’ any of your feelings, no matter how much something in you may want to. You can only send them underground. In exile, parts of us become wilder, darker, lonelier, crueler. When they return from exile, or act from exile, they are not a pretty sight.”
Can Focusing really help with self-criticism and harsh self-judgment?
Yes, and it’s one of the areas where people most consistently report significant shifts. Many people who’ve tried years of therapy, positive affirmations, or mindfulness and still live with a relentless inner critic finally find relief with IRF.
The shift is usually more gradual than dramatic or immediate. But many people report that even one or two Focusing sessions begin to change the quality of their relationship with their inner critic for the better.
How do I stop being so hard on myself?
A simple first step: the next time you notice the inner critic, try saying to yourself, “I’m sensing something in me is saying (insert the critical idea here).”
That small shift in language, from being the critic to noticing the critic, can create just enough space to begin listening rather than struggling.
Our free introductory course, Transform Your Relationship to Your Inner Critic, includes a practice specifically for working with inner critics that takes about 15 minutes, and can make all the difference.
Do I need a therapist to work on my inner critic with Focusing?
No. One of the things that makes Focusing distinctive is that it’s designed to be practiced as a self-help skill. Many people work with their inner critic entirely through self-guided Focusing or with a Focusing partner, someone who has also learned the process and takes turns listening.
That said, if your inner critic is very severe or connected to significant trauma, working with a trained Focusing-oriented therapist or practitioner can provide important additional support. You can find out more about one-to-one Focusing sessions with Ann here.
Courses to Help With Inner Critics
Transform Your Relationship to Your Inner Critic
Get our free, short video course and discover a revolutionary process for shifting how you show up when your inner critic comes calling.
Sign up for our free e-course and get helpful ways to start feeling better about yourself.
Radical Gentleness
5-Module Downloadable Audio Course
When your mind is a battleground and you’ve become your own worst bully, it can be hard to find peace… Are you ready to take it easier on yourself? Make your move from self-blame to inner acceptance with the Radical Gentleness audio course!
Loving the Unlovable:
Transforming Shame and Self-Blame
3-Module Interactive Video Course + Community
If you suffer from shame or lack of self-love, even occasionally, this course can help you shift how you view (and how much you appreciate) the most “unlovable” parts of yourself.
Finding Freedom From Inner Critics
21 Days of Online Video Trainings + Community
Life is much harder when you have an inner critic telling you to feel bad about who you are. Learn a loving, life-enhancing way to change how you experience self-criticism so you can move forward with more confidence, self-compassion, and inner peace.
SHIFT
Interactive Video-based Training + Online Community
This program will teach you the Inner Relationship Focusing process and how to apply it to your daily life. Learn how to pause and get a larger sense of what’s happening in the moment, bring acceptance to the things you experience throughout your day (feelings, thoughts, etc), and apply the process of Focusing to inner critics, decisions, releasing blocks, and more.
Available at your convenience as soon as you register, from anywhere you can connect to the internet.
Price range: $97.00 through $237.00Articles, Tips, and Videos About Inner Critics
Tips to help with Inner Critics and Increasing Self-Compassion and Self-Confidence